Nordeast Nest is Solar Powered!

**Updated with pictures**

We have been in our house for the past 6 years and we finally have had the opportunity to install solar panels.  This had been the plan all along durning the design process and later during the build.  I had attended a neighborhood meeting and one of the offerings was a home improvement loan that also covered solar panels.  This peaked my interest and thought to take a look at a system again to see what the return is on the investment along with the estimate production.  Here is what I will cover in this post:-

  1. Taking the first step

  2. Financials

  3. Evaluation process with the installer and final plans.

  4. The install process and duration.

  5. The results from the last 6 months of running the system.

Taking the first step!!

Each person that reads this has a process they tend to follow, this is what I did.  After we moved into our home in 2015 we setup an appointment with a local solar installer.  The basics of any appointment utilizes satellite images to view the homes roof for a couple of reasons.  The position of the roof for optimal solar gain in addition to potential size of system you could implement.   There are lots of different websites that you can utilize to map out what a predicted system would look like.  The installer you would work with should always be able to give you an estimate for size and performance of a system free of charge.  At the time of when we considered the project we also reviewed the technology available at the time.  From the reading and research we did pointed to a quick growth in improvements and reduction in price per panel.  We decided to hold off on the project and keep an eye on technology, pricing and federal benefits.  This also gave us the opportunity to understand our energy usage through a full year weather cycle.  

When we did finally decide it was time for the project we considered a few installers.  But settled on All Energy Solar as we found them to be the longest in business and thus gave the comfort of potentially addressing system problems throughout the lifeline of the system (~25 years).  First call was with a sales representative who went through a common process of satellite image review of house and potential system size.  The software used will quickly provide kWh output from any particular size system accounting for predicted solar gain data from your area.  A proposal is given and you have to make a decision within about two weeks, take advantage of that and have other installers contacted to compare and contrast the potential delta in pricing.  Here is the proposal we had (it changed) for consideration and began collecting electrical billing info to help calculate the use pattern return on the project compared to the monthly loan payment.  This also helps in understanding how to maximize the system design you would need to utilize production.


Financials & Pricing

The price of the system is dictated by a number of factors:- panel output, size of the array and the installer.  Installers will provide the total cost and will also deduct the federal/state incentives and electrical company buyback (10 year period in MN case) as part of final overall cost.  Note that the federal credits were are 26% of the system cost and have now began to decrease, also some state incentives have expired within MN.  Finally your energy company buyback rates could change from year to year, but once you sign the contract it is locked for a specific rate and period (usually 10 years).

Now to pay for this you have a few options:- Cash is always one way.  Some banks provide home improvement loans to cover the project, some bigger solar companies offer loans as well.  Finally we came to find our solution by doing a little more search, which was low interest loan provided by non-profit organization called MN Center for Energy and Environment MNCEE.org.  They provided us with lowest rate for this project, but we also capitalized on a little program offered in our neighborhood for home improvement through the same organization for a 1% lower than the base rate! 

Site evaluation and final plan

All Energy Solar finalizes the plan by having a technician come on site to evaluate the electrical box, installation path and area.  They also provide you with a year cycle for potential solar energy gain for system.  The latter will be necessary for your loan approval since a condition of providing one is to prove energy saving/return on investment.  A few things to keep in mind for the evaluation; our home was designed with a roof angel providing maximum solar gain for the system.  We had also had roof to basement conduit installed with proper electrical panel and spacing for additional meter outside.  These things may not be necessary for you, but I recommend you ask about details of install since this will eliminate any second guessing later.  An example I can provide is noting the conduit we had in place vs. typical install that would run a conduit along the outside of house.  Again this may not be something you worry about, but asking and understanding every step helps you learn more about the system and provides you a level of comfort with the installer our working with on your project.  During the evaluation you would receive a solar access and shade report, here is what our average calculation for our roof.

The install

This took about 3 days total from start to finish and perhaps it would be faster.  Our roof had a deep pitch that introduced the need for additional safety precautions and it was during deep winter cold (3rd week of December).  First day basically was all the electrical work and wiring for the system getting things ready to receive wires from the transformers on roof in addition to the solar meter.

From left to right:- main house meter, new panel meter, solar switch box, system box.

From left to right:- main house meter, new panel meter, solar switch box, system box.

Next day focused on laying tracks for all the panels and beginning to install the transformers and some of the panel rails.

Final day was completing the install and finalizing all the electrical components.  The action system activation takes a few weeks to get all the inspections and the power company to activate the meter and service.  Note that our system does not store access production it simply gets sold back into the grid.  We considered battery storage but we have lived in our neighborhood for 18 years and lost power only a couple times that we can remember.

The results

After running the system for the past 5.5 months we have seen a total average production of about 1.5 MwH.  Our monthly average usage is about 1.1 to 1.3 MwH, making the system capable of addressing all our needs.  It ended up taking about 2 months for our power company to credit our account with all the production we put in the grid.  This resulted in a $0 monthly balance for 3 months in addition to a lump payment to catch up the account.  We would also receive an annual payment at the beginning of each year (not 100% sure how that is calculated).  He did not install any additional monitoring tools outside of what comes with the system.  Some people chose to do a pinpoint usage monitor for appliances, car, lights etc.  Here is what we have for daily production report and system health.

Finally if you found this information useful please use this referral link for a proposal meeting with All Energy Solar and for install if you decide to move forward with your project using them.  I definitely would use them again and if you have any questions drop me an email would be happy to share and answer other questions for you!

Passive House Days

The weekend of November 12th was Passive House Days, and once again we opened our home for people to explore and ask questions.  With over 60 people attending we had a great agenda lined up and went as follows:

 

  • Introduction & Passive House Crash Course with TE Studio. We saw many new faces this year and Tim Eian took advantage of that by spending a good amount of time providing information about the performance of our home over the past two years as we tracked gas and electrical usage since day one.  At this point we are happy to continue reporting as-expected results of about 1/3 of total usage of utilities compared to a home in same climate and size.

 

  • Passive House Building Envelope Construction with RJ Stegora Construction.  As always we did have a few builders attend the presentations, comparing and contrasting their projects currently in the works with our home.  It was great to see a cutout of the walls that Ryan put together to help with visualizing what is behind our walls. 
  • Passive House Mechanical System with TE Studio and Zehnder Ventilation Systems. New to the tour this year was a rep from Zehnder Systems.  He took the time to explain the process of installing and the inner-workings of our Comfoair 350.  It was a testament to the air exchange system that at the end of the day the air was fresh in the house even with the large number of guests visting for the day.

 

  • Passive House Windows with Tanner Windows and Doors.  The demo included a few different models of windows available in the market and a cross section of each to explain in-depth detail of how they preform.

 

  • Interior finishes, fixtures and appliances with InUnison Design.  We concluded with a unique look on the process of researching and choosing green interior materials and finishes.  I especially found interesting how far ahead industrial use of green materials is for interior/exterior finishes, and how one would benefit from looking to commercial suppliers as well, not only for solutions but wider options available.

That does it for 2016!  We look forward to a happy holiday season and will be bringing more product evaluations and sharing new performance statistics in the coming year.

FAQs from the Minneapolis St. Paul Home Tours

We had about 345 people tour our house during the Minneapolis-St. Paul home tour a couple weekends ago.  During the tour, we fielded many recurring questions about our home. Maybe you're wondering the same things too, so here are answers to the frequently asked questions about our nest.

1. Why is the porch roof at an angle? Does it have a function?  

It really just adds a touch of whimsy.  While designing our home, we told the architect that we wanted asymmetry in the design, and wanted a home that combines modern design with traditional elements, such as an open front porch. The angled porch roof was a unique design element that Tim came up with and we love it.  It wasn't meant to have a function, but ultimately we have noticed that the higher porch ceiling to the south allows more light into our large front window, and the lower porch ceiling over the front door makes it feel cozy and welcoming.  (Link to blog post)

2.  Are you happy with the house?  Does it perform as you expected?

Absolutely, yes.  It's probably impossible not to be happy with a house you put a lot of time and energy into designing, and the Passive House approach just makes it extra comfortable. As far as the utility bills, they are far lower than we used to pay next door, despite the much larger finished square footage and volume.

3.  It feels so spacious inside!  How many square feet is it?

The home is 900 square feet per floor, so a total of 2700 square feet.

4. Can you use the attic space?

Nope, there is a 24 inch blanket of cellulose insulation up there, providing an R value of at least 70.

5.  Do we recommend our architect/builder/designer?

We absolutely highly recommend our architect (Tim Eian), builder (Ryan Stegora) and designer (Christine Frisk).  To have a successful home project, keep in mind that you need a rock-star team, and as the homeowners, you are the leader of the team.  The more precise you can be about your design preferences, the better.  While exceptionally talented, they are not mind-readers, and so if you clearly communicate your expectations, everyone is happier and the project is a success.

6.  How much more  does it cost to build a Passive House?  

This is a hard one to answer.  Not only is our Passive House comfortable with low utility usage, it is also extremely durable and requires minimal maintenance over the long-term.  As far as up front costs for extra building materials and labor, the estimate is about 15 to 20% more expensive for the cost of construction.  

7.  Is the basement floor heated?

No, it's not heated but is does have 6 inches of foam insulation below the slab. This provides an R value of about 30.  The cement floor doesn't feel cold, which is why people ask.  This is just another example of a low-tech (simple) way to provide comfort without active heating.  It costs more up-front, but the difference is noticeable and will last the life-time of the building without maintenance.

8.  Do you have solar panels?

Not yet.  The angle of the south roof is the optimal pitch for flush-mount solar panels when the budget allows. For now, we have signed up for the Windsource program through Xcel Energy which means we pay a little more on the electrical bill to ensure the kWh we use is generated by wind, a renewable resource.  By putting extra money into the construction of a low energy home based on Passive House, we dramatically reduced our family's carbon footprint and that of future families that will call it home.  

9.  Why are there 2 back doors?

We asked for a design with a strong connection to the backyard.  One door is our everyday entrance to the mudroom.  The second door acts as a giant kitchen window providing a direct view of the backyard garden from the moment you enter from the front of the house.  This door also functions as the entertainment door to get to the backyard patio from the kitchen with ease.

10.  What would we have done differently?

It seems like there should be a few obvious answers to this question, but we both can't think of anything that we would have done differently.  

Have we missed a burning question of yours?  Let us know in the comments and we'll do our best to answer.  Thanks for reading!

 

 

 

Minneapolis/St. Paul Home Tour 2016

This weekend our home will be open for the Minneapolis-St. Paul home tour featuring "Real homes. Real people. Real ideas." At our house this means real bubble gum to scrape off the ceiling before this tour. All are welcome! We'd love to see you. Our architect and builder will also be here to answer questions about Passive House construction. Open Saturday, April 30 from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. and Sunday, May 1 from 1-5.  LINK HERE

Alkatout family photo March 2016 MSP home tour.jpg

Now we're cooking...with Induction!

When we went shopping for appliances, we were surprised to learn that an induction cooktop was recommended for our energy efficient home.  We were used to cooking with gas and didn't have plans to change.  Once we learned about induction cooktops, we were pretty excited about the concept.   We tested our relatively new cookware for magnetism, a requirement for induction-ready pots and pans, and luckily they passed.  If you're considering making a switch from your beloved gas cooktop or old-school electric cooktop, you really can't go wrong with induction.  Here's why we love it.  

The heat is generated in the pan itself (through the resistance to electromagneticlly induced currents) and so the cooktop does not heat up and glow red like old-school electric cooktops or have an open flame like gas cooktops.  The major benefits to this approach are:  

1. Safety for the kids

2. Efficient use of energy- it generates the heat where its needed.

3.  Precise control- You can make a boiling pot immediately go to a gentle simmer and back up to a boil just as fast.  It's amazing- really.

4.  It's Quick!  We get a large pot of water to boil in 5 minutes!  The "speed boost" button is my favorite.

5.  Timers to turn off the heat.  Each burner can individually be set to a timer, and the cooktop will turn off the burner, essentially stopping cooking because it is so responsive.  This feature surprised me one day when I was distracted by the kids, and my pasta was not overly cooked to mush.  I was impressed.  

6. Easy to clean- We sure do not miss cleaning those gas grates that actually never looked as nice as on day one.  This induction cooktop looks clean and fabulous, and you can even safely wipe up messes while cooking because the heat doesn't transfer beyond the bottom of the pan.

7. Comfortable cooking- no sweating over an overly hot cooking surface.

If you ever visit the Nordeast Nest, we'd be happy to do a demo! 

 

 

 

 

 

 

New Car- It's Electric!

All of a sudden, our 2001 VW Jetta needed many costly repairs to keep going. We decided it was time to replace our commuter and errand vehicle, and began looking into environmentally-conscious options.  We started researching hybrid cars, but then considered all-electric cars.  The main concern with electric cars is their limited range before needing a recharge. Our home in NE Minneapolis is centrally located in the Twin Cities and only 6 to 10 miles from work, which limited the miles we drove the VW Jetta in 14 years to 135,000 miles.  That's 9,642 miles a year on average, or 26 miles a day. We've heard that the typical average is 15,000 miles/year, so we use the car about 40% less than average, in large part due to our strategic urban home location.   After looking at our daily use needs for a small car, we decided an electric car with a full-charge range of 65-100 miles would be a good fit for us.  We ended up finding a 2014 BMW i3 with 5,000 miles on it, and took it for a test drive. The rest is history.

All we can say is, Wow!  The car silently and effortlessly zooms to the speed limit...or beyond.  It is how I imagine driving a space ship would feel.  It is a fun bonus that the color of the car we found is "solar orange" and matches the back doors of our house.  Perfect.  We've owned our electric car for 2 weeks.  We plug it into a regular outlet at night and it's ready for the next day. There's a smart phone app to monitor the charging status and estimated range, and to schedule pre-conditioning times to automatically heat the interior before departing on cold days.  We are excited to eliminate the need to visit the gas station for this vehicle, and we haven't needed to fill our other vehicle since we bought it. (It is definitely our preferred ride.)  We've calculated that it will cost about $7 per week to charge the car with our typical 30 miles per day usage. This is based on 4.1 miles/kWh (info from our app) and our electricity rate of $0.14/kWh.  We are part of the Windsource* program through Xcel Energy, which means that we pay a little extra to ensure the amount of electricity we use is wholly generated by wind power, a great source of renewable energy.  Our electric car is a dream to drive; we absolutely love it.         

Mom, how do you tell an electric car from a gasoline car, just by looking at it? ... It doesn’t have a tailpipe!
— Our 9-year-old son, Malik

 

   *The Windsource program is an easy way to commit to clean energy to reduce emissions.  Currently, the Windsource program has 96,000 supporters who funded the production of 345,000 megawatt-hours of emissions-free energy in 2015.

 

Tour our Nest!

Our Nordeast Nest will take part in International Passive House Days on Sunday, Nov. 15 from 11am to 3pm.  The architect (Tim Eian), builder (Ryan Stegora) and interior designer (Christine Frisk) will all be there, along with us- the homeowners (Julie and Tarek Alkatout).  Come and see what Passive House is all about!  A guided tour will start at 11:15 am.  

P.S. We still haven't turned our heat pump on this fall!  

Heat Pump Chilling Out

From Top down:- Outside Temp, Second Floor, Basement Temp, and Main Floor.

From Top down:- Outside Temp, Second Floor, Basement Temp, and Main Floor.

This is our first fall in the home, and so we're curious how long we'll go into the season before needing to turn on the heat pump.  So far, the house has stayed extremely comfortable without active heating.  The average high temp for October 2015 so far is 58 F and the average low temp is 43 F.  We had a night or two when the temperature dropped to 31 F, and we were still warm inside.  According to a weather website, there have been 12 heating degree days in MN this October, defined as days cool enough to warrant heating. Last night our oldest boy actually said he was too warm sleeping at night.  Let's blame that on heat rising to his top bunk.

The Photo Shoot Part II

A few weeks back we had Corey Gaffer back to our home to take final pictures of the exteriors.  The results were amazing and the process was enjoyable to watch and experience. We have become accustomed to cars driving by the front of the house and minutes later to see the same car in the ally.  Most enjoyable is the foot and bike traffic as we get a chance to chat and answer questions about the roof lines, build process and Passive house building methodology.

Day Shots ...

Dusk Shots ...